
Hotel Monteleone
Best for staying in the heart of the French Quarter, with quick access to Bourbon Street, Jackson Square, and the riverfront.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Monteleone is a large, family-owned historic hotel in the French Quarter with a rooftop pool, rotating Carousel Bar, and Spa Aria — good for travelers who want to be in the middle of French Quarter nightlife and sights. The Pontchartrain Hotel is a 4-star historic boutique on St. Charles Avenue in the Lower Garden District — a better fit for travelers who prefer a quieter, characterful stay near Magazine Street and streetcar lines.
Updated · about 1.5 mi (2.4 km) apart

Best for staying in the heart of the French Quarter, with quick access to Bourbon Street, Jackson Square, and the riverfront.

Best for travelers who want a smaller, boutique stay on St. Charles Avenue with easy access to Magazine Street and the streetcar.
When Hotel Monteleone wins: Choose Hotel Monteleone if you want to be in the middle of French Quarter action, value an iconic on-site bar (the Carousel Bar), need a rooftop pool and a full-service spa, or require extensive meeting and event space.
When The Pontchartrain Hotel wins: Pick The Pontchartrain Hotel if you prefer a quieter Garden District address, boutique-scale rooms and character, and proximity to Magazine Street restaurants and the St. Charles streetcar.
Bottom line: Both are historic New Orleans hotels; Hotel Monteleone keeps you in tourist central with big-hotel amenities, while The Pontchartrain Hotel offers a smaller, neighborhood-minded alternative on St. Charles Avenue.
| Category | Hotel Monteleone | The Pontchartrain Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, historic French Quarter landmark with high-rise scale and classic public rooms | Historic boutique hotel with Lower Garden District character |
| Location | 214 Royal Street — one block from Bourbon Street and walking distance to Jackson Square | 2031 St. Charles Avenue — Lower Garden District, short walk to Magazine Street |
| Size | About 570 rooms across roughly 14–17 floors (large property) | 106 guestrooms (boutique scale) |
| Ages / policy | All-ages property; reservation holder must be at least 21 to check in; children welcome | All-ages property (no adults-only restriction published) |
| Pools / waterfront | Heated rooftop pool reserved for hotel guests (open daily 6:00 AM–10:00 PM) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Criollo Restaurant, Carousel Bar & Lounge (revolving bar), Acqua Bella Poolside Bar | Silver Whistle Cafe plus 2 restaurants / 2 bars listed in the supplier listing |
| Spa & fitness | Spa Aria (massages, facials, packages) and a 24-hour rooftop fitness center | Not published |
| Accessibility & transport | Wheelchair access via Bienville Street; valet parking only; close to streetcar | Wheelchair-accessible paths and elevator; valet parking (surcharge); near streetcar |
| Meeting & events | Extensive event spaces (24,000–27,000 sq ft across numerous ballrooms and meeting rooms) | Smaller-scale meeting/banquet options consistent with a boutique hotel (specific sq ft not published) |
| Guest rating / stars | 4-star, large historic property (widely rated and reviewed) | |
Hotel Monteleone puts you directly in the French Quarter — one block from Bourbon Street and an easy walk to Jackson Square and the riverfront.
Stay here if you want immediate access to French Quarter sights and nightlife.
The Pontchartrain Hotel sits on St. Charles Avenue in the Lower Garden District — quieter than the Quarter and close to Magazine Street shopping and dining.
Choose this hotel if you prefer a neighborhood stay with easy streetcar access to downtown.
Hotel Monteleone is a large property with a long list of room types and suites across many floors.
Good if you want many room options and straightforward hotel services in the French Quarter.
The Pontchartrain Hotel is boutique in scale with roughly 106 guestrooms and a defined set of room names.
Expect a smaller, more intimate room inventory with several named suites for families or groups.
Hotel Monteleone offers multiple well-known on-site venues — a full restaurant, a legendary revolving bar and a rooftop pool bar.
Pick Monteleone for iconic drinking spots and a full-service restaurant in the French Quarter.
The Pontchartrain Hotel lists on-site dining and drinking options suited to a boutique hotel experience.
Choose The Pontchartrain Hotel for smaller-scale, neighborhood-oriented dining and bar options.
Hotel Monteleone's signature amenity is its heated rooftop pool and adjoining Acqua Bella bar.
If a guest-only rooftop pool matters, Monteleone delivers a reliable year-round option in the Quarter.
Pontchartrain Hotel supplier listing does not publish a pool; details about an on-site pool are not provided in the supplied facts.
Pool info for The Pontchartrain Hotel is not published in the supplied listing; check with the property for current amenities.
Hotel Monteleone combines an on-site spa, a 24-hour rooftop fitness center and late-night bar entertainment.
Monteleone works well if you want spa services plus late-night entertainment without leaving the hotel.
The Pontchartrain Hotel lists nearby fitness access and on-site lounges; supplier materials do not publish an on-site spa.
Pontchartrain is suitable for neighborhood nightlife and streetcar evenings; spa details are not published in the supplier listing.

Stay at Hotel Monteleone to be steps from Bourbon Street, Jackson Square and the riverfront.

The Pontchartrain Hotel offers a smaller, characterful stay on St. Charles Avenue near Magazine Street.

Hotel Monteleone has the Carousel Bar (revolving) and a heated rooftop pool reserved for guests.

The Pontchartrain Hotel places you in a quieter Lower Garden District setting while keeping downtown a short ride away.
Hotel Monteleone — it sits one block from Bourbon Street in the French Quarter.
Hotel Monteleone has a heated rooftop pool reserved for guests; The Pontchartrain Hotel's supplier listing does not publish a pool.
No — both properties are all-ages in their published materials; Hotel Monteleone explicitly welcomes families.
The Pontchartrain Hotel — it's a short walk to Magazine Street and neighborhood restaurants.
Explore how Hotel Monteleone stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·